Do medical residents with rural upbringing show less decline in empathy during training? A report from a rural family medicine residency

Authors

William J. Crump, Univiersity of Louisville School of Medicine Trover Campus at Baptist Health Deaconess MadisonvilleFollow
Craig H. Ziegler, University of Louisville School of Medicine Office of Graduate/Undergraduate Medical EducationFollow
R. Steve Fricker, University of Louisville School of Medicine Trover Campus at Baptist Health Deaconess MadisonvilleFollow

Author Credentials

William J. Crump, MD, Craig H. Ziegler, Ph.D. R. Steve Fricker, MPA

Keywords

Rural upbringing, medical resident training, empathy

Disciplines

Medicine and Health Sciences

Abstract

Purpose

Our focus in this study was to determine if demographic variables, including specifically rural upbringing, showed any association with a measure of empathy among family medicine residents at a rural site.

Methods

We surveyed 40 residents annually using the Jefferson Scale of Empathy (JSE) from 2016 to 2020 and compared scores between residents with rural vs urban hometowns. The response rate was 98/99 (99%) of completed survey opportunities.

Findings

There was no significant difference in JSE scores of rural vs urban residents at baseline, and both groups showed a decline after the PG-1 year. However, the rural-raised residents showed a significantly different rebound after the PG-2 and PG-3 year, with the urban-raised residents actually showing a slight continuing decline (p=.023 and p=.033).

Conclusion

These preliminary findings among family medicine residents at a rural site suggest that rural background residents might regain empathy better than urban background residents during the course of their training. Further study should validate our findings and address possible explanations, including the importance of cultural concordance with the patient population served. This and other hypotheses will be explored in further studies with focus groups and other contemporaneous measures.

Recommended Citation

Crump WJ, Ziegler CH, Fricker R. Do medical residents with rural upbringing show less decline in empathy during training? A report from a rural family medicine residency. Marshall J Med. 2022; 8(1) DOI: https://doi.org/10.33470/2379-9536.1350.